top of page

Are Medicare Advantage Plans Good for Cancer Patients

Choosing between Traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage can be a tough decision. This decision becomes even more critical for cancer patients. Should you choose the flexibility that comes with Traditional Medicare, allowing you to select any hospital or doctor?

Or opt for Medicare Advantage with its enhanced benefits like dental, vision, and over-the-counter drugs? This leads us to the question, are medicare advantage plans good for cancer patients? In this continuously evolving healthcare environment, making such a decision can be complicated.

In the CareTalk episode, “Is Medicare Advantage Fit For Cancer Patients?"John Driscoll and David Williams weigh the pros and cons of Medicare Advantage for cancer patients.

Traditional Medicare Vs. Medicare Advantage

Traditional Medicare, often referred to as fee-for-service Medicare, mostly caters to individuals over 65, along with those with disabilities or end-stage renal disease. Approximately half of the beneficiaries rely on traditional Medicare. It consists of Part A (hospital insurance), Part B (doctor visits and other outpatient services), and Part D (outpatient drugs). Most people also get Medigap to cover things that traditional Medicare doesn't cover, for instance, deductibles and co-pays.

Medicare Advantage, on the other hand, is Part C. This plan combines Part A, Part B, and usually Part D. It is run by private health insurance companies and is akin to regular managed care. There is a limitation on networks, and prior authorization is needed, but it does offer added benefits such as dental, vision, transportation, and meals.

medicare advantage paperwork

Pros and Cons of Medicare Advantage Plans for Cancer Patients

While Medicare Advantage (MA) plans offer several benefits for cancer patients, including out-of-pocket limits and comprehensive coverage for additional services like dental and vision care, limitations exist. These include restricted provider networks,prior authorization requirements for certain treatments, and limited coverage for some services.

Additionally, cost considerations like higher premiums for certain plans are important factors for cancer patients. Ultimately, the suitability of an MA plan depends on individual circumstances, including the stage and type of cancer, treatment plan, financial situation, and personal preferences.

Are Medicare advantage plans good for cancer patients
If I have to go one way or the other, I would say that I would go with the traditional Medicare is the fee for service Medicare. And that is actually based on my own experience in my family. After diagnosis, brought them for care in a very advanced medical center here in Boston. That would have probably been difficult to do, if not impossible, under Medicare Advantage. Making an Informed Decision: Evaluating the Implications - David (CareTalk)

Making an Informed Decision About MA Plans for Cancer Patients

It's worth noting that there isn't a great deal of published data on whether traditional Medicare is better than Medicare Advantage, especially when we focus on their implications for cancer patients. But one thing is clear, the key difference between these two types of Medicare lies primarily in the flexibility and cost implications. With Traditional Medicare, you have the freedom to choose any provider in any part of the country, while with Medicare Advantage, you are restricted to in-network providers and have lower out-of-pocket costs.

But when it comes to managing cancer, the type of healthcare coverage you have matters a lot. For instance, a research study published in the Journal of Clinical Oncology showed that patients under traditional Medicare were more likely to receive treatments at teaching hospitals and less likely to suffer complications compared to those under Medicare Advantage. Cancer, unlike other diseases, requires specialized treatment, and as such, you may want to consider a plan that offers you the most flexibility in terms of choosing a treatment center.

Bottom Line: Are Medicare Advantage Plans Good for Cancer Patients?

Traditionally, Medicare Advantage patients have lower out-of-pocket costs and access to added benefits like dental, vision, and over-the-counter drug coverage. However, the caveat is that Medicare Advantage plans often have more restrictive networks, which can potentially limit a patient's choice of treatment center, especially for complex cancers that demand specialized facilities and professionals.

Therefore, the choice between the two ultimately boils down to a trade-off between costs and the flexibility to choose where you would like to get treated. However, the emphasis should be more on the quality of care and treatment than on the type of coverage. The primary consideration should be your care, and how well your coverage enables you to manage your cancer.

Ultimately, the decision between Traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage depends on your situation, healthcare needs, and financial situation. And remember, the focus should always be on quality care - not just coverage.

But the main reason, John, is the ability to go to any provider in the country. And that is a bigger issue with cancer than with other things. With cancer, there are hundreds or thousands of diseases and you want to go where there's a lot of specialization. - David (CareTalk)



CareTalk is the only healthcare podcast that tells it like it is. Join hosts John Driscoll (President U.S. Healthcare and EVP, Walgreens Boots Alliance) and David Williams (President, Health Business Group) as they provide an incisive, no B.S. view of the US healthcare industry.



bottom of page